Settlers and Palestinians unite in opposition to Israeli annexation

Some Israeli settlers agree with their Palestinian neighbours in the occupied West Bank that the Jewish state's plan to annex part of the territory would undermine their years-long reconciliation efforts. Palestinian Khaled Abu Awwad and Israeli rabbi Shaul Judelman live just a few miles away from each other in the southern West Bank, the former in Bethlehem and the latter in Tekoa,...

al-monitor Palestinian Khaled Abu Awad (L), and Israeli settler Shaul Judelman say they are concerned that Israeli plans to annex parts of the occupied West Bank will undo years of reconciliation efforts by their movement Roots Photo by MENAHEM KAHANA/AFP.

Topics covered

Jul 6, 2020

Some Israeli settlers agree with their Palestinian neighbours in the occupied West Bank that the Jewish state's plan to annex part of the territory would undermine their years-long reconciliation efforts.

Palestinian Khaled Abu Awwad and Israeli rabbi Shaul Judelman live just a few miles away from each other in the southern West Bank, the former in Bethlehem and the latter in Tekoa, a settlement considered illegal by the international community.

The two are the joint directors of Shorashim-Judur, or Roots in Hebrew and Arabic, a movement founded in 2014 to establish dialogue between Israelis and Palestinians sharing the West Bank, which has been occupied by Israel since 1967.

US President Donald Trump's controversial peace plan paves the way for Israel to annex parts of the West Bank, including Jewish settlements considered illegal under interna

tional law.

In a statement this week Roots said unilateral annexation would constitute an "aggression" that would "stand in opposition to the principle of mutual respect" which is "the foundation for advancing peace and security".

Roots has its headquarters in Gush Etzion, a bloc of two dozen settlements and outposts near Bethlehem that some have speculated will be among the first Israel would annex.

At a recent meeting there Abu Awwad and Judelman shared the concerns they have if Israel went ahead with its annexation plans.

On a terrace surrounded by olive trees, Abu Awwad compared annexation to a "declaration of war" that could bring violence.

"Any unilateral decision cannot be a sign of reconciliation but on the contrary, raises the level of the conflict," he said.

"Iron Curtain"

" (photo by: MENAHEM KAHANA/AFP)

Sitting next to him, Judelman said "it is not enough to oppose annexation, people from both societies must unite and propose something else".

"But it takes political leaders with courage to break the iron wall between our two societies," said the rabbi, his head covered with a large skullcap.

"We have a generation of Israelis who never met a Palestinian but only saw a terrorist on TV, and a generation of Palestinians who only saw an Israeli soldier and this is what Israelis are to him," said the rabbi, his head covered with a large skullcap.

Judelman said the 1993 Oslo peace accords -- which split up the West Bank into three zones -- created a divide between Israelis and Palestinians by saying "you are here and you are there".

"It cannot work because both peoples are connected to the entire land," he said.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's centre-right coalition government had set July 1 as the date it could begin implementing annexation but the date passed with no announcement.

His office said separate talks were ongoing with US officials "on

the application of sovereignty" and with Israeli security chiefs.

Israeli annexation plans sparked sharp criticism in the international community, Arab world and within Israel itself, with the lack of apparent progress on the issue raising speculation Netanyahu was not seeking immediate action.

One of the many thorny issues in the possible annexation move was the question citizenship for Palestinians in areas Israel annexed.

"Any plan that does not put front and centre the equal rights and mutual benefits that every Palestinian and Israeli deserves will not bring us closer to peace but rather distances us from it," the Roots statement said.

To Judelman, annexation is just the latest attempt of one side to force a solution on the other since the collapse of the Oslo accords, which were meant to be temporary and lead to the formation of a Palestinian state.